E cigarettes good or bad? Take our poll
Suddenly, e cigarettes seem to be everywhere and so far, there is no regulation at the local, state or federal levels. There are a growing number of bans, but the science has only done some studies on the vapor and its effects on users, as well as people who are around secondhand vapor.
California State Senate Bill 648, which was introduced in late February, requires e cigarettes to be regulated as a tobacco product and be included in existing smoke free laws.
Stanton Glantz, professor of medicine at the University of California, said he supports the bill becoming law. Glantz told Team 10 the state should mandate that people cannot use an e cigarette where traditional cigarettes are banned.
But many users argue e cigarettes are a better choice than tobacco cigarettes.
(See results of e cigarettes tested in a special lab, tonight on 10News at 11 p.m.)
Christine Gentry smoked at home, in the car and at her job in a casino until she started using e cigarettes. And she has not gone back.
“It doesn' t smell bad,” said Gentry. “It' s much cheaper. No yellow teeth.”
Gentry is the chief operating officer of Vapure, a San Diego based e cigarette company with seven stores.
The company' s store in Mission Valley, which is inside a regular office building, was busy the entire time Team 10 visited the shop and interviewed Gentry.
She said they do not sell e cigarettes as a smoking cessation device, though she said many customers turn to the product to quit smoking tobacco cigarettes.
“If they ask us, we tell them there are over 4,000 chemicals in a cigarette and they are hundreds of dollars a month,” Gentry said. “In electronic cigarettes, there are four ingredients. We make it ourselves and the price is a fraction of the cost.”
She said those ingredients are pharmaceutical grade nicotine like you find in the patch, vegetable glycerin, propylene glycol and flavorings for the refill liquid made by food grade companies.
Glantz gave an overview on how e cigarettes work.
“The way an e cigarette works is it heats up a mixture of nicotine, propylene glycol and other chemicals and that heated mixture becomes an aerosol which is inhaled deeply into your lungs to deliver the addictive drug nicotine,” she said.
The professor and other critics believe e cigarettes do not help people quit smoking because users reportedly use e cigarettes and cigarettes at the same time.
“Most of the people, about 80 percent of people who use e cigarettes, keep smoking regular cigarettes,” said Glantz.
Young adults, children
Critics of e cigarettes say the companies market to children.
“It is very much like old fashioned cigarette marketing, with the addition of all these high tech and kiddie things, like flavors,” said Glantz.
E cigarette users can choose from hundreds of different flavored liquids. Some of the favorites at Vapure are strawberry mango freeze, melon and snickerdoodle.
Critics say the flavors are a draw for kids a way to get younger people to get into smoking.
Gentry said her business does not market to kids and does not sell to underage customers. She added that police have been to the shop to make sure.
“We aren' t posting billboards in front of elementary schools, but at the same time, if we are marketing to children, then so is cherry vodka or vanilla rum,” Gentry said.
But Glantz refutes the industry' s denial. He said smoking for kids is at an all time high. He points to a Center for Disease Control Study that says cigarette use has doubled among kids in middle and high school.
READ CDC report on Electronic Cigarette Use Among Middle and High School Students United States, 2011 2012
“They could well be serving as a new route in nicotine addiction for adolescents,” he said, adding the slick advertising is attractive to kids, too.
Advertising
The government banned television and radio ads for cigarettes in 1970 and ads on smokeless tobacco were banned in 1986.
But big tobacco is back on air, now pushing electronic cigarettes.
Actor Stephen Dorf did a series of ads for Blu, an e cigarette brand owned by the tobacco company Lorillard, and Reynolds America is running a commercial in Colorado for their e cigarette, Vuse.
“They are using celebrities. They are using sex. They are using glamour,” Glantz said.
He also said research shows the e cigarette ads are triggering relapses in people who have long quit smoking.
The e cigarette industry maintains its product can only help smokers, not hurt them.
Proposed ban
San Diego County is considering a ban of e cigarettes indoors, with the proposed guidelines expected to be released in the coming days.
“The most important thing to do about e cigarettes is to include them in clean indoor air laws can' t be used indoors where you can' t smoke conventional cigarettes,” said Glantz.
Team 10 asked San Diego' s mayoral candidates where they stand on banning e cigarettes indoors and in public places.
“As a father of two young kids, I tell them not to smoke cigarettes,” said mayoral candidate Kevin Faulconer. “So, I want to do everything I can on education to make sure that people know what' s the right thing to do and what' s the wrong thing to do.”
Mayoral candidate David Alvarez said, “I' d definitely be interested in looking at that proposal and what other cities are doing to make sure that we continue to keep the public safe, and public healthy, and so we' ll look at that as those come forward.”
Gentry believes the bans are misguided and not fair for e cigarette users.
“It' s really unfair to be put in a smoking section, experiencing secondhand smoke, standing with the smokers, when we tried for some years to quit smoking,” Gentry said. “Now we are put in the same area with the smokers.”
Vista, Carlsbad and San Diego State University already have bans, and so do some major cities across the country, such as New York.
Big tobacco invests in e-cigarettes. should you? – 1 – – msn money
Marlboro cigarettes – answers.com
Still, if its mainstream focus lacks downtown hipness, NJOY has generated buzz with its high profile investors and anti smoking “cred.” NJOY’s roster of supporters include billionaire Sean Parker, of Facebook (FB) and Napster fame, and former U.S. Surgeon General Richard Carmona, who will head a NJOY research committee that will study the e cigarettes. The company is positioned for a possible takeover by one of the major tobacco players or a possible initial public offering, analysts say, though that could be some time into the future.
“Some smaller players will be taken over by Big Tobacco, and NJOY could eventually go public,” says Adriana de Lozada, an analyst for private company research firm PrivCo. “NJOY has done a great job of positioning itself, but it’s not ready to do an IPO, not yet. Growth is important, but so is size to be able to go public and to compete in this market.”
Lorillard (LO), the scrappy No. 3 cigarette maker behind giants Altria (MO) and Reynolds American (RAI), has moved aggressively with its blu brand, says Kwon, adding that the company has “always been an innovator.” It’s trying to bring a touch of Mad Men style glamour to cigarettes, and bringing smokes back to the tube for the first time in four decades with ads featuring television celebrity Jenny McCarthy puffing up the benefits of e cigarettes by saying “it’s not sexy” to smell like an ashtray and pointing out she doesn’t have to freeze outside to smoke a cigarette.